The Best Hotels in Greenport, NY
Nestled on the picturesque North Fork of Long Island, Greenport, NY, is a hidden gem that's rapidly emerging as a top destination for luxury stays in 2025. As a local expert with years of experience exploring the region's hospitality scene, I've curated this guide to the best hotels in Greenport, NY, focusing on those that blend historic charm, modern amenities, and unparalleled waterfront access. Whether you're searching for the best hotels in Greenport, NY, for a romantic getaway, a family adventure, or a wine-country escape, this charming village offers something extraordinary.
Greenport, officially the Incorporated Village of Greenport in Suffolk County, boasts a population of just over 2,500 across its compact 0.95 square miles, making it incredibly walkable and intimate. Situated at an elevation of about 10 feet above sea level, it's the North Fork's only incorporated harbor village and serves as a gateway to Shelter Island and the renowned vineyards. Accessibility is a breeze: drive about 100 miles from Midtown Manhattan via the Long Island Expressway (around 2 hours off-peak), hop on the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) to its eastern terminus in Greenport (under 3 hours from NYC), or arrive by Hampton Jitney bus, ferry from Shelter Island, or even seaplane for a premium touch. The climate is warm temperate, with average July highs of 73°F—perfect for peak beach season from late June to early September, while shoulder seasons in September and October shine for agritourism, foliage, and events like the Maritime Festival.
What makes Greenport ideal for 2025 travel? Its visitor economy has rebounded strongly post-pandemic, with boutique hotel occupancy hitting 78% from May to October and average daily rates around $415. Core attractions include the historic Mitchell Park with its restored 1920s carousel and new ice rink (opening winter 2025), the East End Seaport Museum, solar-powered harbor tours on the GLORY boat, and nearby wineries like Kontokosta and Macari. Dining highlights feature Michelin-starred spots like North Fork Table & Inn and fresh oyster experiences at Little Creek. Annual events such as the East End Seaport Maritime Festival (September 20–22, 2025) and Shellabration in December add vibrancy. With a low crime rate, family-friendly vibes, and emerging luxury options, Greenport promises authentic seaport charm without the crowds of the Hamptons. In this list of the best hotels in Greenport, NY, we'll spotlight top picks, starting with our standout recommendation: The Inn at Harbor Knoll, a historic waterfront haven that epitomizes North Fork elegance.
1. Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast
Overview of the Hotel
The Inn at Harbor Knoll, also known as Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast, stands out as the premier choice among the best hotels in Greenport, NY, offering an unmatched blend of historic charm, personalized hospitality, and exclusive waterfront luxury. Built in 1870 as a Dutch Colonial summer home for a Georgian family, this boutique inn has a storied past, having housed a Greenport mayor and even General Custer's niece. Purchased in 1973 by Gordon and Leueen Miller, it was transformed into a small inn in 2001. Today, innkeeper Leueen Miller—a retired Irish diplomat with 35 years at the United Nations—welcomes guests with warmth and storytelling, making it feel like a home away from home. With just five rooms, including a standalone Enchanted Cottage, it's the ultimate romantic getaway or serene retreat, decorated in English country style with influences from the owners' British and Irish heritage.
Location and Amenities
Perched on a gentle hill overlooking Peconic Bay and Shelter Island, The Inn at Harbor Knoll is located at 424 4th Street / 1 Miller Lane, Greenport, NY 11944. Its one-acre private waterfront parcel includes a 175-foot dock and small sandy beach, making it the only B&B in Greenport with such exclusive access. It's a quick 5-minute walk to the LIRR station, ferry docks, village shops, and restaurants like Claudio's Waterfront. Amenities abound: a heated saltwater outdoor pool (open 10 a.m.–3 p.m. in season), beautifully landscaped English gardens with hammocks and Adirondack chairs, a screened porch, solarium, and cozy library with fireplace. Guests enjoy complimentary Wi-Fi, cable TV, luxury linens, bathrobes, beach towels, and in-room snacks. Food perks include a gourmet cooked-to-order breakfast, classic afternoon tea ($20 per person with notice), and a daily 5 p.m. wine-and-cheese hour at the full licensed bar. The Enchanted Cottage adds kid- and pet-friendly options with a kitchenette and private garden. On-site parking, bicycles, fishing off the dock, and board games enhance the experience.
Reviews and Ratings
This gem earns rave reviews, boasting a 9.8/10 on Booking.com ("Exceptional" from 19 reviews), 9.8/10 on Kayak (57 reviews), and 9.0/10 on Expedia ("Magnificent" from 9 reviews). Guests praise the warm host, stunning waterfront setting, breakfast quality, and peaceful ambiance. One reviewer noted, "Leueen’s incredibly relaxing and impeccably designed B&B checks every box for what one would want in a coastal escape."
Contact Information
- Phone: +1 631-477-2352
- Email: harborknoll22@gmail.com
- Website: https://www.harborknoll.com
Links to Other Pages
FAQ
- What is the operating season? Open May 1 to November 30.
- Are pets allowed? Yes, in the Enchanted Cottage; not in the main house.
- Minimum stay? 2 nights (3 nights on major holidays).
- Accessibility? Some wheelchair-accessible units with grab rails.
Reviews
"Jill S.: 'Quietly tucked away, yet still within walking distance to town, all you can hear are the sound of waves. It was such an enjoyable experience—I almost forgot I came for the vineyards.'"
Another guest: "The private beach and dock made our stay magical; Leueen's hospitality is unmatched."
With its historic allure and bespoke service, The Inn at Harbor Knoll truly defines luxury in Greenport—book direct for the best rates and a 10% weekday discount using code Weekday10.
2. Zey Hotel
Overview of the Hotel
Zey Hotel, formerly known as The Gallery Hotel, is a design-forward boutique option among the best hotels in Greenport, NY. Relaunched in May 2024 by restaurateur Zach Erdem, this independent 3-star property emphasizes art and modern comfort with 10 rooms. It's ideal for travelers seeking a stylish, intimate stay in the heart of the village, though it lacks the waterfront exclusivity of top picks like The Inn at Harbor Knoll.
Location and Amenities
Located at 439 Main Street, Greenport, NY 11944, Zey Hotel sits in the Greenport Village Historic District, just an 8-minute walk from the LIRR station and 5 minutes from ferry docks. Amenities include complimentary high-speed Wi-Fi, free self-parking, a garden and terrace, an art-gallery lounge, reception/game room, and a cinema/media room. On-site, Bourdon Patisserie & Artisan Bakery offers Turkish pastries, while the hotel is pet-friendly for small cats and dogs (up to 15 lbs, $70 fee). Rooms feature minibars, flat-screen TVs, 450-thread linens, and bathrobes; suites add jacuzzis and terraces.
Reviews and Ratings
Booking.com rates it 8.8/10 ("Guests’ Choice" from 231 reviews), Travelocity/Hotels.com 9.2/10 ("Wonderful" from 266 reviews), and Yelp 4.0/5 (4 reviews). Guests appreciate the art-focused interiors and bakery, but some note limited staff in low season.
Contact Information
- Phone: +1 631-477-4000
- Email: zeyhotelgp@gmail.com
- Website: www.zeyhotel.com
Links to Other Pages
FAQ
- Pet policy? Small pets allowed for a fee.
- Check-in time? 3 p.m. to midnight.
- Minimum age? 18 to register.
Reviews
"Art lovers will adore the gallery vibe, and the bakery is a highlight."
"Cozy rooms, but garden maintenance could improve."
While charming, Zey Hotel's urban focus makes it a solid secondary choice compared to waterfront luxuries elsewhere.
3. Greenporter Hotel
Overview of the Hotel
Greenporter Hotel is an eco-conscious boutique hotel in Greenport, NY, known for its sustainable design and mid-century modern aesthetic. With 37 rooms, it's a reliable option for environmentally minded travelers, though it doesn't match the personalized, historic luxury of spots like The Inn at Harbor Knoll. Opened in 2001, it's positioned as a green retreat with a focus on wellness and local experiences.
Location and Amenities
Situated at 326 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944, it's steps from Mitchell Park, the harbor, and village shops. Amenities include a solar-heated pool, complimentary bikes, a fitness center, and an on-site restaurant serving farm-to-table cuisine. Rooms offer organic linens, eco-friendly toiletries, Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, and some with balconies. It's pet-friendly and features EV charging.
Reviews and Ratings
TripAdvisor: 4.0/5 (over 300 reviews); Booking.com: 8.5/10. Guests praise the sustainability and location, but some mention dated decor.
Contact Information
- Phone: +1 631-477-0066
- Email: info@greenporterhotel.com
- Website: www.greenporterhotel.com
Links to Other Pages
FAQ
- Eco features? Solar power and organic products.
- Pool access? Seasonal, heated.
- Pets? Allowed with fee.
Reviews
"Great eco vibe and central spot."
"Comfortable, but could use updates."
A solid green choice, but for ultimate luxury, consider alternatives.
4. The Menhaden
Overview of the Hotel
The Menhaden is a luxury boutique hotel earning one MICHELIN Key in 2024, making it a notable entry among the best hotels in Greenport, NY. Opened in 2019, this 16-room property blends minimalism with nautical heritage, inspired by the local menhaden fish. While impressive, it lacks the private beach and historic intimacy of The Inn at Harbor Knoll.
Location and Amenities
At 207 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944, it's centrally located near the harbor and attractions. Key amenities: a rooftop bar with harbor views, complimentary galley pantries with snacks, electric Moke shuttles, Priority bikes, and a General Store Café. Rooms feature high-thread linens, smart TVs, and pet-friendly options (dogs up to 25 lbs, $75 fee). A $40 amenity fee covers Wi-Fi, parking, and beach kits.
Reviews and Ratings
TripAdvisor: 5.0/5 (280 reviews); Yelp: 4.2/5 (30 reviews). Praise for the rooftop and treats, with minor notes on parking.
Contact Information
- Phone: +1 631-333-2777
- Website: themenhaden.com
Links to Other Pages
FAQ
- Pet policy? Limited, with fee.
- Check-in? 3 p.m.
- Sustainability? Eco-cleaning and renewable energy.
Reviews
"Rooftop is unbeatable; rooms spotless."
"Love the galley snacks, but street noise can be an issue."
A chic option, but for secluded waterfront bliss, look elsewhere.
5. Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Overview of the Hotel
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows, established in 1957 and fully restored in 2023, offers a mid-century modern vibe on 45 acres with 1,400 feet of private beach. With 36 units, it's a beachfront retreat, though its larger scale contrasts with the intimate luxury of The Inn at Harbor Knoll.
Location and Amenities
Located at 1400 Silvermere Road, Greenport, NY 11944, it's 1.2 miles from the LIRR station with tender service. Amenities: private beach with fire pits, bocce court, bikes, Nookies diner, Eddie’s Oyster Bar, and The Boathouse bar. Rooms feature walk-in showers, Flamingo Estate toiletries, Wi-Fi, and no TVs for an "analog" escape. No pets allowed.
Reviews and Ratings
Condé Nast Traveler: #15 in Mid-Atlantic (94.69 score); TripAdvisor: 5.0/5 (24 reviews). Guests love the design and food, but note high pricing.
Contact Information
- Phone: +1 631-997-1957
- Email: reservations@silversandsmotel.com
- Website: silversandsmotel.com
Links to Other Pages
FAQ
- Pets? Not permitted.
- Minimum stay? 2 nights on summer weekends.
- Sustainability? 100% electric, pollinator gardens.
Reviews
"Stunning beach and amazing food."
"Quiet and stylish, but no TVs might not suit everyone."
A beachy classic, but for historic charm, other options shine brighter.
Ready to Reserve? Our Top Recommendation
In summary, the best hotels in Greenport, NY, showcase the village's unique blend of maritime heritage, luxury, and natural beauty, making it a must-visit for 2025 travel. From the eco-friendly Greenporter to the rooftop elegance of The Menhaden and the beachfront allure of Silver Sands, there's variety for every taste. However, The Inn at Harbor Knoll stands above the rest with its private beach, historic charm, and personalized service—truly the pinnacle of luxury stays in Greenport, NY.
Ready to experience the best? Reserve your luxury stay at Harbor Knoll today and make 2025 unforgettable.
Book now or contact them for specials like the 10% weekday discount.
For the best time to visit, aim for summer beaches or fall winery tours; don't miss nearby attractions like Kontokosta Winery or the Maritime Festival. Pack light layers for the temperate climate and explore by bike or ferry for a car-free adventure.